By Koto
Quick Verdict
Short answer: Canmake Creamy Touch Liner is the standout. We ranked 5 Japanese eyeliners that are popular on @cosme and actually shippable to the US via Amazon. Stock status varies by item and is noted individually below.
As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases.
At a Glance
| Rank | Product | Price | Status | Best For | Buy |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| #1 | Canmake Creamy Touch Liner (Canmake) | $11.99 | ✅ In Stock | Best budget everyday liner | Buy on Amazon → |
| #2 | LoveLiner Pencil Eyeliner (msh) | $19.50 | ✅ In Stock | Best for mature or sensitive lids | Buy on Amazon → |
| #3 | Heroine Make Smooth Liquid Eyeliner (Isehan) | $15.00 | ✅ In Stock | Best for oily or hooded eyes | Buy on Amazon → |
| #4 | Cezanne Double Eyelid Eyeliner (Cezanne) | $18.99 | ✅ In Stock | Best for natural tear-trough shading | Buy on Amazon → |
| #5 | Majolica Majorca Line Expander (Shiseido) | $17.99 | ✅ In Stock | Best colored liner for cool undertones | Buy on Amazon → |
Methodology
We started with @cosme’s (Japan’s largest beauty review platform) popularity ranking for eyeliners, filtered to Japanese brands with an active Amazon US listing. Full methodology →
Out-of-stock items stay in the list below, clearly labeled, since restocks on these listings are common.
#1. Canmake Creamy Touch Liner (Canmake)
Amazon US status (as of 2026-08-03): ✅ In Stock — $11.99 (price varies by shade, $11.50-$16.99) (sold through a third-party Amazon storefront rather than an official Canmake US store, so double-check the seller line before you buy)
@cosme rank: #1 in Eyeliner (overall)
Pros
- From @cosme reviews: reviewers who’ve tried other liners keep coming back to this one for its combination of easy application and staying power at a low price → good for anyone who wants a reliable daily liner without spending much
- From Amazon US reviews: praised for a smooth, creamy glide that’s easier to control than liquid formulas, with one reviewer calling it a dupe for a $38 Hourglass pencil → good for beginners or anyone switching off liquid liner
Cons
- From @cosme reviews: a gel pencil like this needs occasional setting powder over it to get truly all-day wear on its own → not a one-step solution if you sweat heavily
- From Amazon US reviews: the tip runs a little thick for sharp winged looks and can snap if twisted or pressed too hard → not the pick for precision wing artists
Koto’s take: This is the liner Japanese reviewers reach for when nothing else needs to happen at the register. It glides on right and holds its color, and that’s why it’s sat at the top of this category for years.
Where to buy: Buy on Amazon
#2. LoveLiner Pencil Eyeliner (msh)
Amazon US status (as of 2026-08-03): ✅ In Stock — $19.50 (this is msh’s LoveLiner pencil formula; the liquid R5 version ranked on @cosme does not currently have an active Amazon US listing, so this is a different SKU from the same line)
@cosme rank: #2 in Eyeliner (overall, liquid R5 version)
Pros
- From @cosme reviews (on the liquid formula this pencil shares a brand with): reviewers who normally struggle with a shaky hand describe the line as unusually stable and easy to control
- From Amazon US reviews: the pencil glides on with light pressure and doesn’t tug, even on mature or sensitive eyelids → good for older users or anyone prone to lid irritation
Cons
- From @cosme reviews: some reviewers say an ultra-fine tip like this wobbles more easily than a standard liquid brush → not ideal if your hand isn’t steady
- From Amazon US reviews: a few buyers found the color faded over a full day, similar to other pencils they’d already tried → not a guaranteed all-day pick for oily lids
Koto’s take: LoveLiner earned its @cosme reputation on the liquid version’s precision, and this pencil carries the same soft-glide approach. It’s a fair substitute if you want the brand’s take on fine lines without hunting down the exact Japan SKU.
Where to buy: Buy on Amazon
#3. Heroine Make Smooth Liquid Eyeliner (Isehan)
Amazon US status (as of 2026-08-03): ✅ In Stock — $15.00
@cosme rank: #5 in Eyeliner (overall, Prime Liquid Eyeliner Rich Keep)
Pros
- From @cosme reviews: reviewers repeatedly describe it as the liner that survives a hot, humid Japanese summer without smudging into the crease → best for hooded or monolid eyes prone to eyeshadow-line smudging
- From Amazon US reviews: several US reviewers with oily lids specifically say they stopped getting “raccoon eyes” after switching from Western brands → good for humid climates or anyone who’s given up on smudge-proof claims before
Cons
- From @cosme reviews: this is a stubborn, waterproof formula, which means it needs a proper oil-based remover rather than a quick wipe
- From Amazon US reviews: one reviewer said it flaked off after a gym workout, and another didn’t like the glossy “vinyl” finish it leaves when first applied → not for everyone’s taste or every workout routine
Koto’s take: The Japanese standard for a liquid liner is “doesn’t move until you take it off on purpose,” and this is one of the few Amazon-available options that clears that bar for hooded and oily lids.
Where to buy: Buy on Amazon
#4. Cezanne Double Eyelid Eyeliner (Cezanne)
Amazon US status (as of 2026-08-03): ✅ In Stock — $18.99
@cosme rank: #6 in Eyeliner (overall)
Pros
- From @cosme reviews: the muted greige and pink shades are called out for creating a realistic shadow rather than an obvious “drawn on” line → best for natural tear-trough or double-eyelid definition, not bold liner looks
- From Amazon US reviews: reviewers say it blends into the skin tone well enough to use for tear-trough shading without looking like makeup
Cons
- From @cosme reviews: it can fade with heavy sweat since it’s built to be sheer rather than intensely pigmented → not the pick for a hot-weather all-day wear test
- From Amazon US reviews: a reviewer noted the liquid tip picks up foundation and glitter over the course of wear, muting the color further → touch up if you’re layering it over full-coverage base
Koto’s take: This isn’t trying to be a bold liner, and that’s the point. It’s the closest thing on this list to invisible definition, which is why it keeps winning “shadow makeup” awards in Japan.
Where to buy: Buy on Amazon
#5. Majolica Majorca Line Expander (Shiseido)
Amazon US status (as of 2026-08-03): ✅ In Stock — $17.99 (sold through a third-party Amazon storefront rather than an official Shiseido US store)
@cosme rank: #15 in Eyeliner (overall)
Pros
- From @cosme reviews: the pink-grey and brown-toned shades are specifically praised as flattering for cool (blue) undertones, with reviewers calling out how well they blend with eyeshadow and blush
- From @cosme reviews: praised for smooth application and long wear even in colors beyond basic black or brown
Cons
- From @cosme reviews: a couple of reviewers switched from black to a brown shade because black didn’t suit their hair color as well, so shade-matching matters more here than with a plain black liner
- The Amazon US review base for this listing is still thin, so treat US-specific wear reports with some caution until more buyers weigh in
Koto’s take: If you want a colored liner rather than another black one, this is the shade range Japanese reviewers reach for. It’s less about drama and more about matching your existing makeup.
Where to buy: Buy on Amazon
FAQ
Is the LoveLiner sold on Amazon the same product ranked on @cosme? Not exactly. @cosme’s #2 ranking is for LoveLiner’s liquid R5 formula, while the version currently listed on Amazon US is the brand’s pencil eyeliner. Both are made by msh under the LoveLiner name, but if you specifically want the liquid R5, you’ll need to look for a Japan-based retailer or import seller.
Will these hold up in humid US summers the way they do in Japan? Reviews suggest yes for the liquid formulas built for Japan’s humid summers, like Heroine Make. US reviewers with oily or hooded lids report similar smudge resistance. Sheerer shadow-liners like Cezanne aren’t designed for maximum staying power, so expect more touch-ups in heat.
Are these official US listings, or imports? Several of these, including Canmake and Majolica Majorca, are sold through third-party Amazon storefronts rather than an official brand US store, which is common for Japanese drugstore cosmetics that don’t have a dedicated US retail arm. Check the seller name on the product page before you buy if that matters to you.
Prices and stock status verified as of 2026-08-03, from Amazon.com with a US delivery address. Amazon inventory changes frequently — always confirm current price and availability before purchase.